I especially enjoy that they removed car lanes to make space for this.
Fun fact: in budapest theres no reason to drive a car yet people still do it. For the vast majority of people commuting in budapest public transit is better than cars. Its faster, cheaper, more convenient but its not your car. So there are these car brained lunatics who could take the metro and tram for a 20 min commute but decided they have beef with the envorinment and instead sit in a fucking traffic jam for 40 mins. Tho if you live outside of the city proper and in a suburb/agglomeration the typical commute times could be above an hour for both modes.
Wife lived there for 7 years while at St.Istvan. Sub and trams are one of the best I have seen. Best part is how the IKEA is situated at a bus/subway hub.
Spot on.
Tho if you live outside of the city proper and in a suburb/agglomeration the typical commute times could be above an hour for both modes.
I’d say that’s improving as well, with new public transportation lines being implemented. Of course, it depends on where you live.
Yeah lets say one of my family members made an overly optimistic property purchase in érd and now has to to suffer with commute related consequences
They removed parking and sidewalk and trees on the sidewalk, not carlanes.
They certainly did remove carlanes, and kept tge sidewalk, But your point on the trees certainly stands valid.
They clearly removed sidewalk on the right side. It’s pretty much the same with grass added in the middle to look better.
Okay so remove trees to make things better!
Does anyone know if there is a reason for moving the tram tracks? Seems like an expensive change, especially since I dont really see a benefit in this image.
Maybe to provide a safe area for pedestrians to wait between the tracks? Other than that probably aesthetics, as the other commenter mentioned.
Also, I don’t think moving tram tracks is that expensive if you’re already tearing up the whole street. Tram tracks probably also have a fixed lifespan, so at some point you need to replace them and/or their bedding.
I’m the top pic, you have the stop in between the tracks. This is the better (albeit more expensive) configuration for subways, but in this case, passengers need to cross the tracks after getting off, which is inefficient, less comfortable and less safe. Also this seems to be taking part of a larger trend in Europe of making car travel in cities purposefully more difficult (I’ve seen plenty pedestrian isles enlarged to entirely too big for what they need to be and as a pedestrian who doesn’t know to drive, my only guess is it was made to create an artificial bottleneck for traffic. This is corroborated by the people who drive me whenever I need it.)
Edit: specifically
and the one on the other side seems to serve no purpose, but bottleneck traffic. Presumably with pedestrian safety in mind.
Could just be aesthetics, honestly
Straight downgrade.
Went from having wide sidewalks, big trees and natural shade (especially on the right) to less sidewalk, and no shade.
There’s more ‘green’ in the photo now but it’s just useless grass and manicured trees sandwiched between a road and a tram track where nobody on foot can or would want to access it, so it seems absolutely pointless.
Should have put all that nice green on the kerbside where it benefits people.
They’ve created a nice photograph whole ignoring what people actually need.
hard agree. we need to spread awarenes that grass does not equal nature. most countrys have very other grass naturally and this is an import. trees, bushes, native plants do so much more for the enviourment even when its on plain dirt. were there birds living on that street? well, not anymore.
Hopefully, in some 10 years when the new trees are grown it will be more enjoyable. Now, I agree with you. I particularly mourn the trees, because it will take a decade to get new ones to those sizes
deleted by creator
The actual tracks are NOT grassy. It just has grass around the sides of the tracks.
YTF did they remove all the trees!?!?
likely because tree roots can be a hassle for surrounding sidewalks
Yeah! Less sidewalks and shade trees, more lawnmower grass nobody will ever touch!
Still a car sewer, even if a slightly less ugly one.
And the sidewalk on the right got smaller! And the beautiful, large trees are gone 😔 Except for the splash of color, this almost feels like a net downgrade, IMO. Good on them for at least maintaining their public transport infrastructure, though!
In the first picture you can actually see somebody standing under a shade tree. It was nice to have grassy areas near the sidewalk. Too bad.
there are some new ones planted back there
This redesign is pretty flawed but the “new” image must be also already pretty old. The trees look substantially larger by now: google-maps
There is no doubt that the wall of green from the trees make this a much nicer place to be now than it used to be. Also while not by a lot, car capacity has been reduced. It looks like at least on one side one lane has been removed for traffic and some turn lanes have been removed or shortened.
That said, the sidewalks are not super narrow but not wide either, for such a central avenue and the madness is that they have been made narrower, at least on one side. A much better way to rearrange would have been to move the green strips to the sides, between sidewalk and road traffic, while turning the tram track into a proper green track. Not necessarily grass, that is hard to maintain. Bratislava has for example new “green” tracks. Those are with some hardy plants, mosses or some other non-grass stuff. It looks quite nice and appears much more robust.
I do not share the extreme opposition to pretty much any grass in a city that has become en vogue in the US because there huge areas are planted with grass, trimmed and treated to extreme extends, controlled neihgbourhood associations. This is no such thing. It is a fairly small area in an extremely central location. Mind you also that the issue that in the US a lot of the grass has been brought from Europe so it is not actually native there. … but this image is from Europe. I can’t tell if the grass there is of the kind that grows naturally in Hungary, would be interesting to know.
It’s a start. But you can also have real grassy tracks instead of just some around it or do more than just gras.
Examples:

And it’s not like Hungarians can’t possibly know this: while I am not sure whether there are any in Hungary, both Vienna and Bratislava are very close to Hungary and have sections like this.
i think they stuck to this because emergency vehicles use the same tracks, and when the trams are out for whatever reason, buses often go there too. but yeah, the outermost lane needs to be a bus lane, and i have no clue where the bike lane is supposed to be
No.









