• 2 Posts
  • 23 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: May 19th, 2024

help-circle











  • That there is a playbook when these uprisings are imperialist, doesn’t prove or disprove which ones are, or are not imperialist.

    There are funded uprisings, which aid Imperialist aims, and there are uprisings that do not aid imperialist aims.

    Saying (and presenting an substack screed that says) uprisings are imperialist, is not the same as proving that the uprisings mentioned, which are current are Imperialist backed. If you’re going to make that claim, and have it be believed you’ll need more than “other uprisings have been western backed”.

    It’s kind of trash to see a protest and just assume that without evidence. It’s defeatist doomer rhetoric.




  • Wealth under Capitalism is logarithmic, and controlled from the top down. Someone’s parents who own two homes are closer to being in your class strata than being billionaires (orders of magnitude wealthier).

    There’s the lobbying class of wealth, and the voting class. Owning two homes and having low millions still isn’t in the lobbying class.

    We need to keep the distribution of wealth within certain limits from the poorest to the richest.

    The ultra rich are the problem, not the merely very very rich. The wealth GAP is the problem. That gap is due to billionaires, not millionaires.

    Traversing the gap from regular person to millionaire is somewhat believable. Traversing the gap between regular person to billionaire - is very unlikely.

    Go watch any video, or read a text about how wealth is distributed currently. I don’t have it out for millionaires (the petite bourgeoisie, many of whom can see the problem of wealth distribution is unhealthy for everyone), it’s the wealth-concentrated couldn’t-get-here-without-family billionaires and high millionaires that are the problem.

    Finding an appropriate hard limit and defining it in a way that is demonstrably present, exists for a specific reason is a difficult problem. At what point do we limit the range, and what will motivate politicians to install that cap (over taking a bribe) is the problem.