

You don’t want to acknowledge who is destroying who here…
That’s so sad. I feel sadness for you.
Human


You don’t want to acknowledge who is destroying who here…
That’s so sad. I feel sadness for you.


You keep using words like fascist, imperialism “self-determination” as if labeling something proves your argument.
Even if Ukraine has a serious far right problem, that doesn’t make its entire government fascist or prove NATO orchestrated Maidan. Even if NATO expansion contributed to Russian security concerns, that doesn’t automatically justify invading Ukraine. You’re confusing explanations for political events with justifications for them.
Your appeal to self determination is especially inconsistent. Why does Donbas’s desire to separate from Ukraine count as genuine popular agency, while Ukrainians’ desire to move closer to Europe is dismissed as submission to imperialism? If people have the right to determine their political future, that principle cannot apply only when their preferences align with Moscow. And a separatist movement’s claim to represent a population doesn’t automatically establish a legitimate mandate to secede, particularly under armed conflict and foreign military involvement.
You also keep saying Russia “merely” assisted resistance to fascism. “Merely” is doing a lot of work there: it sanitizes Russian intervention without examining Russia’s own strategic interests. If Western powers exploit political divisions to expand their influence, why assume Russia doesn’t exploit those same divisions to maintain its own sphere of influence?
Finally, accusing me of believing Russians are “genetically evil” is a straw man. Criticizing the Russian state is not expressing hatred toward Russian people. You haven’t identified anything I’ve said that supports that accusation.
The underlying issue is your double standard: Western influence is imperialism, Russian influence is self-defense; Ukrainian nationalism proves fascism, while separatist nationalism proves self-determination. If your principles only apply when they benefit Russia, they’re not principles of anti-imperialism or self-determination. They’re geopolitical loyalties dressed up as universal principles.


Removed by mod


I think this you are confused of several different things: legitimate regional divisions within Ukraine, the real influence of far-right nationalists, the nature of the Maidan revolution, and Russia’s own geopolitical and economic interests.
First, Yanukovych’s support was indeed concentrated in eastern and southern Ukraine, and many people in Donbas genuinely opposed the change of government in 2014. But acknowledging their agency does not mean accepting the claim that the war was simply a spontaneous civil war caused by Kyiv refusing to respect their wishes. The conflict developed through a combination of domestic political divisions, the seizure of government buildings by armed groups, Russian support for separatist forces and eventually direct Russian military intervention. You conveniently ignore Russia’s role in escalating and sustaining the conflict.
Second, which should be very obvious, the existence of far right groups does not establish that NATO orchestrated a coup or that the Ukrainian state is fundamentally a Nazi project. Far right organizations were disproportionately visible in street confrontations, but they performed poorly in subsequent national elections. Svoboda won approximately 10.4% of the vote in the 2012 parliamentary election, falling to around 4.7% in 2014. That hardly supports the idea that Ukrainian politics as a whole was taken over by a Nazi movement. And if we take a peek at the Russian side, where Nazi iconography is flaunted and the state is a dictatorship with obvious (statistically proven) fake elections.
Third, the loan dispute is more complicated than the claim that Yanukovych simply chose a humane Russian loan over a cruel IMF loan. That just a silly idea. It was a geopolitical bargain that would strengthen Moscow’s leverage over Ukraine. Ukrainians were protesting not merely over the technical terms of a loan, but over the government’s reversal on European integration, corruption, police violence, and the increasingly authoritarian direction of the state. You cannot reduce the entire movement to NATO manipulating Ukrainians over a financial dispute. Yet you do that. Why?
Finally, the argument about Russia’s economy does not really establish what you want it to establish. Industrial capacity is not the same thing as broad economic prosperity,I. Economic independence from Western finance is not the same thing as economic independence from global capital. Oligarchic class, dependence on hydrocarbon exports, capital flight, inequality… The fact that Russian capital is controlled domestically rather than by Western investors does not mean that Russian people benefit.
US and NATO have their own strategic interests, sometimes destructive. That deserves criticism. But Russia is also an imperial power with its own regional ambitions, and its invasion of Ukraine cannot be explained as merely a defensive response, even more so confusing they are tearing down cities leaving just rubble and death. Acknowledging that does not require pretending their actions are identical or that smaller countries have no right to determine their own political future.
So I would reject the accusation of chauvinism. Criticizing Russian nationalism, oligarchic capitalism, or military intervention is not an expression of hostility toward Russian people or Russian culture. Likewise criticizing Ukrainian farright movements does not mean denying Ukrainian sovereignty. The consistent position is to recognize the agency of Ukrainians, including those in Donbas, while also recognizing the agency of Russians and the interests pursued by the Russian state. Neither Washington nor Moscow should get to decide the political future of Ukraine on behalf of Ukrainians.
But you don’t seem to agree? Or you think that its all some conspiracy and Ukrainians actually love Russians.


Removed by mod


Removed by mod


They will stop at almost any ceasefire.
Russia will break almost every ceasefire.
And the the meat being grinded is Russians. Even Russian mil bloggers are starting to admit the horrific loses.


That’s completely illogical, besides being patently wrong. Forced conscription has nothing to do without with it. It’s normal for a country in war.
NATO has no interest in this war. Europe has no real army, no stockpiles of weapons, only token weapons industry. They had to big economic connections with Russia that they can’t even break 5 years into this war. Europe had such a big incentive for this war not to happen they they ignored Russian military annex of Crimea 8 years prior.
America you can see that now they are buddies with Putin. While you could argue that they have some sinister plan to put Russia into war with Europe, it’s just so obvious to see that their foreign policies change daily. There is a clown at the wheel and there is no depth there. They would be happy to control the world economically and Russia is a regional power for them.


Russians want capitulation. Ukraine will do anything to just stop the killing. They can’t win against Russia and America together.
:)