• 0 Posts
  • 10 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 10th, 2024

help-circle

  • But in all seriousness, they’re still unmaintaible slop

    They are definitely more user-friendly and community-maintainable than the closed-source originals.

    Originals are either binaries you can’t modify, or completely black-box inaccessible software someone else runs which you only interact with.

    Having some source code which does almost the same thing, even if it’s buggy, is much better than having nothing at all.

    Of course AI has its own issues and the resulting software is pretty bad. It is a great starting point to be improved tho.






  • balsoft@lemmy.mltoSocialism@lemmy.ml•Authoritarian!
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    2 months ago

    I agree with your overall point, still I think there needs to be some context.

    Here is the graph for USSR’s prison population (I could only find it in russian on yandex, because search engines are so fucked up nowadays):

    USSR really did have a relatively high imprisonment rate throughout its existence, and I think its punishment-focused penitentiary system was one of its worst sides. I’m glad that other socialist states are improving theirs, and I hope one day they can reach a point where prisons in their current form would no longer be necessary.

    As an aside, I find it really interesting that there was a simultaneous increase in prison population in both USSR and the US in the 80s:

    While in the US it was mainly caused by “law and order” politics popularized after the revolutionary movements of the 70s, combined with privatization of prison labor, I couldn’t find any well-sourced explanations for why it happened in USSR.


  • I’m not defending the crimes this woman helped perpetrate, I’m asking what material actions you are advocating for.

    For example, I believe that the rapist should be punished, this woman needs help with the resulting PTSD, and the entire military needs to be dismantled with appropriate punishments for all involved. Requiring them to do labor rebuilding countries they destroyed would be a good start, with harsher punishment for people doing actual war crimes themselves. Being physically violated by a man who’s also an accessory to war crimes is not a valid punishment, it does not advance any of the societal goals of punishment (deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation, retribution), to speak nothing of how inhumane and cruel it is.

    What about you?