• 0 Posts
  • 29 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 10th, 2023

help-circle





  • I get that running as 3rd party is a way to get your issues heard and hopefully change one of the 2 actual parties. But winning is usually not the actual goal (unless it’s a down ballot ticket, but even those have limits).

    First, this doesn’t sound like what is being proposed by this thread. The person in the video thinks 60% of non voters would come out to vote for a 3rd party. And they would win. I agree that the best way forward is to change the parties, not end them (as that isn’t possible in our system).

    Second, how effective is running as 3rd party at actually changing the party? I’m sure some things from Nader eventually made it to the party. If you don’t think he impacted the election, then it’s probably worth it. If you think he gave us 8 years of Bush, 2 wars and 2 lifetime supreme court picks, then maybe not.

    I would present Bernie Sanders as an alternative. He was a 3rd party candidate, but ran as a Democrat. He lost in the primaries but has permanently changed the Democratic party. There are people in office today that would never have considered running if it weren’t for him. He did this without splitting the vote in the presidential election. Hillary lost all on her own.


  • The point of running is to push Democrats to adopt issues important to third party voters. This is why Trump made RFK Jr the HHS Secretary, if he didn’t do that he would have run third party and cost Trump the election.

    I think this is saying 2 different things. 1st, you run 3rd party to get the party to adopt issues. You damage the party in one election to show them they need to adopt issues in the next. There’s a debate here on how effective this actually is vs just running as one of the 2 parties and having your voice heard in the primaries.

    2nd, you threaten to run 3rd party to get a secretarial appointment? This doesn’t sound OK at all… Also doesn’t sound like what anybody in this thread is supporting.



  • Thanks for proving my point. You are incapable of even imagining.

    The argument is that Nader took votes away from Gore in a way that cost him the election. For ease of communicating, I say “if Nader wasn’t on the ballot Gore would have won”. You chose not to engage wirh the intent of the premise but jump into some science fiction world where Nader didn’t run because Homer Simpson went back in time 2 million years and stepped on a leaf and now we’re all lizard people.

    You do not want to have an actual conversation about the issue I’m bringing up.






  • Take 2: I certainly don’t mean to offend. But this isn’t how human conversations work.

    extrapolation isn’t evidence. it’s a hypothesis. come up with a test.

    This isn’t a good point. We’re not in a science lab mixing together chemicals. We also don’t live in a simulation where we can change things and watch the results.

    We’re talking about history. There’s facts, there statistics, there’s opinions, etc. I certainly can’t prove to you with 100% certainty that events would have happened differently if Nader wasn’t running. And if 100% certainty is your bar, then this conversations isn’t worth having.

    I can provide statistics that are convincing to me, and I think should be to others as well. But we aren’t writing scientific journals here. This isn’t the NY times. We’re having a conversation on the internet.