Father, Hacker (Information Security Professional), Open Source Software Developer, Inventor, and 3D printing enthusiast

  • 0 Posts
  • 9 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 23rd, 2023

help-circle


  • I’m not misrepresenting anything. If you take any model and just change the temperature a little bit (it’s a setting that controls the influence of the RNG) you can have wildly different output.

    Different AI providers using the exact same model will have outputs so different using the same exact prompts you’d think they were in different universes.

    They absolutely do not “have the same hallmarks.”

    This stuff is benchmarked to absurd degrees every time a new model comes out. Just look it up already! You’re so obviously arguing from an ignorant position it’s silly.


    1. They do not all write the same. There’s benchmarks for this and if you just do a basic search or actually test them yourself you’ll see that their output differs wildly. Not only between vendors, but been versions of the same model. For example, Claude stopped using em dashes for most output for a while but now they’ve come back.
    2. There’s vastly more than “a handful of models”! Are you living under a rock‽ Go to HuggingFace today and then again tomorrow. There’s going to be a dozen new ones! Probably more!
    3. Changing the back end configuration even a tiny bit can vastly change the output of a model.

  • FYI: Pangram sucks. It’s about as accurate as throwing darts these days.

    A long, long time ago (i.e. 2024) there was only one LLM that was widely used by the populace: ChatGPT. It only had a few versions and they didn’t differ much in how they worded output.

    Now it’s 2026 and we have hundreds of thousands of AI models. That includes over 1000 commercial vendor models!

    Another thing that’s really important that you need to understand is that even if two providers run the same model, their configurations will be different and thus, their output won’t be the same.

    To summarize: There’s no fucking way Pangram can work properly anymore. It’s useless garbage.


  • AI isn’t inherently unethical. The very premise of saying such a thing is flawed.

    Is it unethical to use AI to find new drugs and medical treatments? To use it for physics research? What about regular research? Writing code?

    Where do you draw the line?

    Also, AI was used to design the current crop of fusion reactors and the full potential of that is only just getting started. If it turns out that AI solves all the issues and generates a working fusion reactor design, it’ll make every one of your arguments moot. Because that one achievement will be worth everything. It would “save the world” so to speak (from an energy/emissions standpoint).

    Chatting with an LLM is less impact than driving a car. Think about that for a second before you say using it is unethical. It’s literally more negative for the world for someone to drive a car every day to work than it is to ask an AI to find something on the Internet or write a program in Python.

    Or perhaps your underlying complaint is more about capitalism than it is about AI?


  • Put it into perspective:

    • Everyone doing their laundry uses more water than all data centers combined. Golf courses also use vastly more water.
    • Data centers use about 1-2% of global electricity.

    People driving cars pollutes more as does global shipping, regular old consumerism, etc. The environmental impact of data centers is negligible in the grand scheme of things.

    Now that AI is making open source software the most secure software ever written (the hard way, hehe), not using it to scan your stuff is now considered worst practices and basically idiotic negligence. No company that uses software or anything with firmware can afford to ignore it anymore.

    There’s no way out of it. Accept the new AI reality and push for good regulations. Example: If we made it so that all AI data centers had to be powered via renewable energy on site that would allay most of the energy use/environmental concerns.