• 0 Posts
  • 3 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 29th, 2023

help-circle

  • Ok, yeah that sheds some light on the situation. It sounds like you’re in a gatekeeper role

    I think pushing to force transparency is good, especially if you are getting traction on the issue

    I have also found that the software in question wants to install 40 more packages from its creators personal website. This isn’t disclosed anywhere. And that is objectively shady af imo - but again, probably not actually illegal.

    But this though…That is shady as fuck. Perfectly legal, but that’s a huge red flag. There’s a very high chance they have some data collection packages in there already, it is a reliable way to make money off free software

    It also means the security is “trust me bro”. That’s far more disturbing to me than all the legal and transparency concerns put together. They may not be doing anything bad yet, but it means they could sneak it in easily later


  • Is there any sort of legal situation here?

    Legal action runs on money… So no, legally I’m very confident nothing will come of it

    Ethically? I mean, really ask yourself if your objections would make a difference. Would your concerns be heard and respected, or would you be risking your position for nothing? IDK the situation, but you should consider the situation

    Then ask the more important question, if you could live with this or if it would eat you up inside

    Your concerns are likely valid, but probably no one will thank you for raising a stink about it. In general terms I personally would probably go along with it since it doesn’t seem like a place where I could make a meaningful difference, and that’s the core question of my professional ethics

    But you have to have to keep your own code of ethics. If this violates yours, you should do what you have to do

    Be the person you want to be