I can’t wait to scroll down and read the objections of everyone who actually believes that.
Removed by mod

I don’t think Communism works
Communist revolutions have massively improved the living conditions of the working class in the world, even in capitalist economies (by forcing them to adopt things like the 8-hour working day and basic rights for women).
Even if you want to point to the dismantlement of the USSR, it worked for around 70 years, with the economy worsening when the privatisation started happening under Gorbachyov.
70 years is not “things going haywire quickly”.Removed by mod
“I guess you’ll have to ask the people who died in the last famine ever to strike a famine-prone region if the system that ended the region’s periodic famines is good.”
Countries who frequently suffered from famines yeah, and which would be their last famine ever.
But hey ask the millions of Bengali Indians who died of a man-made famine who were left intentionally to starve to death because as Winston Churchill calls them “breeding rabbits”.
Also the Holodomor famine narrative was being pushed by Nazis. The famine never targeted Ukraine because it wasn’t even intentional. Other states suffered from famine too.
But sorry to interrupt your script, I think your next line is Tibet Uyghur tinyman square?
Removed by mod
Defending famines is certainly one way to argue a point.
I am not defending famines, I am criticizing your fascist propaganda talking points.
I hope you use that argument when pushing communism. I prefer economic policy that does not commonly produce famines.
commonly produce famines? So after Holodomor or the Great Leap Forward, what other famines were there? You should be able to name them! After all they were common!!
Imperial rule of Britain around the world is hardly an economic argument.
You dense cracker that’s what you are doing! You were treating the “Ukraine famine” as a result of Russia’s “imperial rule”. You’re a fucking hypocrite.
If I understand it correctly, China has found a way to have quotas and market price discovery.
For certain goods, a company is obligated to produce x amount of things, and sell it at set price. But everything they produce beyond that, they’re allowed to sell at whatever price to whomever. This keeps a downward pressure on like food prices, while still rewarding extra production.
Removed by mod
And what happened after the GLF?
Odd pattern of pointing toward failure and refusing to point to the success that followed.I think the word for that is ‘selective memory’, in our context maybe we should call it ‘selective history’.
Americans lose thousands of citizens every day to their healthcare system, do we get to try change once the American healthcare system’s deaths sum up to the GLF? Why not stop American deaths now?
Such transparently silly discourse.
Removed by mod
What happened after? Did capitalism play any role?
What the fuck is this deflect lol
Answer the fucking question.
I’ve been thinking of it as akin to the US’s New Deal economy. Still a lot of private ownership and markets, but with state ownership structures across key industries.
It’s funny that you point to the Great Leap forward as an example of why command economy doesn’t work, because (as best I understand it) the Party points to it as an example of what does work; something like “We tried it, it failed. We learned from it, are applying the lessons and trying something else.” It’s only natural that a command economy under-performs against a market economy… the first few times. Same way a conscious organism isn’t going to outpace natural selection and the ecology it produced… at first.
Edit: the points I’m making are less legible without the other half of the dialog.
It’s only natural that a command economy under-performs against a market economy… the first few times.
Shit, take away the differing structures and it’s still only natural for a new economy to struggle at first against an established economy, especially when the established economy has the wealth of a hundred neocolonies to draw from and the new economy is starting from backyard scrap furnaces
Removed by mod
Speaking as a US citizen, we are still experimenting economically, but the choices aren’t made consciously. They’re narrowly restricted to whatever performs best for a company’s stock evaluation this quarter. If someone like a CEO tries to break from that narrow range of maximal short-term profitability, investors have every right to sue and have them thrown out.
Concrete example, AI data-center buildouts are an economic experiment. A specific company - its CEO, a board of directors - may have a series of reasons to justify that choice. But there’s a reason multiple companies all made that choice and its because doing so lets them be perceived as a growth stock. The actual data-centers are incidental.
Edit: the points I’m making are less legible without the other half of the dialog.
That is only true when there is scarcity & looked at in isolation, and even then it doesn’t help with direction. More so, there is the incentive of profit so a lower quantify of goods (eg food) can be produced (or just can’t be allocated due to price even if they are already produced).
“Price discovery” is just a super simplified concept that also leads to incredible inefficiencies.Necessities, if they can be produced, can’t be left to the free market unless you intentionally sacrifice less fortunate (& miss out on their future contributions). It’s a tradeoff of a system, all have them.
And price discovery is a thing in communism too, as well as price regulation is an option in capitalism. Neither economic system can exist without regulation and direction, what’s more efficient is a matter of opinion (eg you could hardly say China isn’t efficient in their advancements, nor deny the political & economic might of USA, or even countless feudal empires of the past, etc).
Removed by mod
ghost cities
Oh no! Anticipating demand and building for it ahead of time, what horror
Capitalism remains the best bad options.
Because liberals like you don’t have the ability to think of a better world.
Most the things that work well in China are pretty much capitalism.
Not capitalism, the capital does not control the country. You are coping because your leaders let pedophiles run your countries without any consequence.
When the government their insentivizes constant building of apartment building, you get ghost cities and a crash.
Ohhhh heyyy I know this, have you looked at these “ghost cities” today? They’re fucking packed. It was because the government was actually doing something called PLANNING which is so utterly alien to Sinophobic fascists like you. But then again, China is no more because it crashed, or they are about to crash, their collapse is imminent. At least that’s how I’ve heard it for multiple decades.
Removed by mod
Have you tried making an argument without ascribing a bunch of random beliefs to the person.
Have you tried making an argument without pushing fascist propaganda?
Please tell me when I became Sinophobic, Fascist, or Liberal in the conversation?
I don’t have to tell you. Your comments on this thread are more than enough proof.
Removed by mod
you get ghost cities
Ghost cities are not a real thing. Literally every one of those “ghost” cities is now occupied. China plans a community in its entirety ahead of time, builds it all in one go, and once completed, people move in. Western media take a snapshot between completion and occupation, and call it a “ghost city.”
This Is What The World’s Loneliest Metro Station Looks Like Today
and a crash
The Chinese state popped that housing bubble intentionally, and they left the investors holding the bag while protecting homeowners. They did the exact opposite of what Obama did in the 2008 housing crisis.
Also capitalism: “These people who never needed to work a day in their lives are the most productive people.”
As a Debs quote:

Lotta seething in the comments
liberals being scratched as usual
I think it was winter that beat everyone.
go more in depth
Russian winters are not for the weak. Germany learned the hard way as many other countries did trying to invade. They basically froze to death or died of attrition because of supply line issues.
For comparison, the USSR was about at the same level of development as Brazil in 1920. And yet within 30 years, the country lead by the Bolsheviks:
- won a civil war against the monarchists after the horrible state of desolation the country was in after WW1
- defeated an imperialist invasion of 10+ western powers (including the UK and USA)
- defeated yet another imperialist invasion by Germany in operation barbarossa, with the eastern front of WW2 being probably the bloodiest conflict in human history.
- Became a superpower rivaling the USA, which had almost a 100 year head start on industrialization, and much more natural resources.
Capitalism doesn’t work
It works as intended, just not as advertised.
Capitalism doesn’t work
It works for a handful of elitist arseholes very very well, which is why it continues to exist. If the elitist arseholes didn’t get anything out of it, the people would be able to try something new and different, and possibly better. So long as the elitist arseholes still get to rule over everyone, they’d allow it.
i’m convinced that the way we self reinforce propaganda upon each other is a bigger culprit – yes, those elitist arseholes created the environment in which that propaganda feels like reality, but we’re ultimately the ones spreading it ourselves.
IMHO, poor education is the culprit. A well educated man is able to criticize a propaganda message, but a poorly educated one just feeds on it.
Most people are given the illusion of having a “good education” but it’s far from that if it doesn’t push you to think outside the box.
Education is probably a majority of that environment that makes propaganda feel like reality – it conditions us to become receptive to the propaganda and reject anything that makes us consider thinking outside the box as subversive at worst and silly at best.
Propaganda is the spark, our culture that spreads it is the kindling. The one who lights the match is responsible for starting the forest fire, but that doesn’t mean we’re powerless to prevent the conditions that cause it to spread.
The data hits like a truck, I just hope people actually read it.
What was the invasion of 10+ western powers? I can’t recall what that could be
The capitalists threw away all pretenses of their own nationalist ideologies and attacked the world’s first threat to their hegemony as a class.
Centralization of power is the problem.
Russian made great leaps forward when they got rid of their oligarchs (monarchy) exploiting the working class.
America also had a great leap forward when they implemented more socialism after the 1930s.
Similarly in Europe starting in the 1950s.
Unfortunately the Oligarchs have been taking back control over the last 30 years or so in all these places, which is why things are getting worse.
Capitalism is a mechanism for central control by oligarchs, but it’s not the only one.
The few places in the world showing rapid progress have been the ones that embrace free trade, with strong social policies and strong regulations against capital concentration.
Every country should have easily accessible wood chippers for billionaires, oligarchs and politicians.
America also had a great leap forward when they implemented more socialism after the 1930s.
???
The new deal
Massive public works programs. Regulation of capital markets. Social security is introduced. 8 hour work day and 5 day work week. Unemployment benefits Tariff removals Banning of child labour Introduction of minimum wage. Establishment of many government regulatory agencies. Public housing programs.
It’s basically what set up the US to become a global superpower until it started getting undermined in the 1980s and the decline we are experiencing now started.

“Socialism is when the government does stuff” ahh
The new deal was a response to the very real growing threat of the communists and socialists in the wake of the great depression, who fought for things like the 8 hour day. It was FDR’s successful project to save capitalism and destroy the left at the same time, by granting welfare and work projects, and taxing the rich to pay for them.
It was not socialism, which entails public ownership of production, and worker control of the state. Both of those socialist goals were thwarted by the new deal. Capitalists remained in power and in full control of the government.
That still isn’t socialism LMAO
The capitalists were still in power, they had to do this because they were losing their legitimacy compared to the USSR, who was looking far better.
It’s basically what set up the US to become a global superpower until it started getting undermined in the 1980s and the decline we are experiencing now started.
It started getting undermined when Amerika longer had any pretense of caring after the fall of the USSR.
No you don’t understand, socialism is when government does stuff!
America also had a great leap forward when they implemented more socialism after the 1930s.
Socialism is when workers own the means of production. Social welfare programs, no matter how robust, are not socialism.
Yeah there really are two definitions in modern terms. And they really should have different names.
Call it democratic socialism then.
It’s people like you who killed Rosa Luxemburg
No, there are no two definitions of socialism, and those things do have different names, one is socialism and the other is welfare programs, you just misuse them even when corrected. And calling welfare programs “democratic socialism” is just as wrong as calling them “socialism”
Agree, it really needs its own term.
Socialism has a long history of being used to present many things. Hell, even the Nazis called themselves socialist.
I think the distinction comes in that Socialism has a definition as an economic system, which is the classical use of it.
Then there is socialism as a political system, which is the one that everyone claims they are as propaganda. It’s the “look at me, I am populist” term.
Then there is Democratic Socialism, which is really just an approach governance and a broad set of policies, not an economic or political system.
Language and politics is messy. It should be simpler.
It is simple, you just dont know what you’re talking about and you’re too proud to understand/admit that you’re talking out of your ass.
It’s all clearly defined, you just haven’t educated yourself, but you insist that whatever you’ve picked up through cultural osmosis is just as valid. It is not.
Social democracy?
It really needs its own definition.The current terminology is messy with lots of misunderstandings.
Democratic socialism is what many people call it, but when you look at their policies, it’s not socialism as an economic system, but socialism as a societal system and group of government policies.
Social democracy is what you’re describing, which is distinct from any kind of socialism. Bourgeouis politicians deliberately misusing terms does not change the definitions of those terms.
Bourgeouis politicians deliberately misusing terms does not change the definitions of those terms.
We’re seeing living proof that it does, and that’s double-plus ungood.
America also had a great leap forward when they implemented more socialism after the 1930s.
How did they implement socialism?? Have you analyzed any of these claims you are making?
Unfortunately the Oligarchs have been taking back control over the last 30 years or so in all these places, which is why things are getting worse.
30 years or so? so like… hmmm… sometime around after 1991? hmmm
The few places in the world showing rapid progress have been the ones that embrace free trade, with strong social policies and strong regulations against capital concentration.
What’s your opinion on China?
I should have been specific, Socialist programs, not total Socialism.
I should also say 45 years, not 30. I am getting old. The wheels started coming off in the 1980s already.
China is an interesting case, as it is one of the oldest civilizations in the world. As a result, it has gone through many of the same social and economic development as others. Yet it has show an ability to reform without collapse or revolution in the last 45 years.
For the average Chinese person, things only really started getting better when China opened to free trade markets in the late 80s. From there they built up into the undisputed champion of industrialization, engineering and technological innovation today. Yet they have largely prevented capitalism from controlling their economy. It’s proof that capitalism is not the source of innovation in modern economies.
The CCP is still a largely authoritarian organization compared to the democracies in Asia, but they have been a largely competent one. Chinese people for the most part are happy because the social compact with their government is working for the most part. Certainly much more competent than the government in places like the US or Russia over the last 30 years. Also better than places like Japan or Korea, who might have superior personal freedoms, they have inferior economic freedoms.
I should have been specific, Socialist programs, not total Socialism.
Welfare is not socialism.
I should also say 45 years, not 30. I am getting old. The wheels started coming off in the 1980s already.
Stop backtracking lmao
China is an interesting case, as it is one of the oldest civilizations in the world. As a result, it has gone through many of the same social and economic development as others. Yet it has show an ability to reform without collapse or revolution in the last 45 years.
Because they are being run by communists who actually plan their shit, even with the mistakes they learn.
For the average Chinese person, things only really started getting better when China opened to free trade markets in the late 80s. From there they built up into the undisputed champion of industrialization, engineering and technological innovation today. Yet they have largely prevented capitalism from controlling their economy. It’s proof that capitalism is not the source of innovation in modern economies.*
It’s fucking socialism, it’s using the contradictions of capitalism to develop their means of productions BUT the important thing that makes it NOT capitalism is that the capitalists DON’T RUN THE GOVERNMENT.
The CCP is still a largely authoritarian organization compared to the democracies in Asia, but they have been a largely competent one. Chinese people for the most part are happy because the social compact with their government is working for the most part.
It’s the CPC not CCP.
Also you say that Chinese people are happy with their government but you HAVE TO TWIST YOUR STATEMENT because you refuse to outright admit it and have to make it still sound bad.
Certainly much more competent than the government in places like the US or Russia over the last 30 years. Also better than places like Japan or Korea, who might have superior personal freedoms, they have inferior economic freedoms.
lol, lmao even
SUPERIOR PERSONAL FREEDOMS?? don’t make me laugh
“superior personal freedoms” to starve and suffer OKAY buddy maybe this freedoms that Westoids keep yapping about to be not great at all!
Oh but for example for Korea, you can not even say positive things about DPRK in the occupied south without landing in jail. Good personal freedoms there.
Removed by mod
sopuli.xyz
A shame that Finland was never de-nazified.
Instance-based dismissal in these slap fights annoys me. I mean, I get it, but still.
When you see the 100th " .ml bad " and “oh I forgot I was on .ml teehee” along with their rampant fascism then you kinda start noticing what kind of instances they come from.
I think that’s WHY it annoys me actually, hahaha
And wrong again Lithuania not finland, the one which got their alphabet banned by the russian empire.
Damn that’s crazy what that feudal monarchy did a hundred years before you were born, you should totally harbor a generational ethnic grudge against Russian people about it.
A feudal monarchy finally defeated by the bolsheviks too.
Well you certainly are being very mad at being liberated from the Nazis lol
Shame that the Baltic chihuahuas were never denazified, either.
Just interested where are you from?
Not from any of the Baltic nazi states.
Ah american
Removed by mod
stop being creepy with your humiliation fetish you Nazi
Nothing will top having the Soviets stomp on them but you certainly are trying!
Removed by mod
Source: Propaganda you learned from American “education”
^ how to say you’re an easily manipulated ignoramus without saying so
Capitalism may suck but Soviet style socialism which is not true communism, sucks too.
when you just make shit up lmao
Yeah, the wealth was controlled by the new Soviet oligarchs like Stalin. I really wish Marxism had a better chance to get established.
I think western meddling is partly to blame for that, but much like what we saw in the French revolution, they got rid of their monarchs, only to have them replaced a few decades later by a dictator like Napoleon that turned cannons on the protestors in the streets.
I’m sure you think Animal Farm is the height of political analysis.
Absolutely not.
Yet even with a simplified story like Animal farm, people are unable to recognize the truth it holds.
Unless society continuously fights against the concentrations of wealth and power, they get Oligarchy or some form of it.
Yet even with a simplified story like Harry Potter, people are unable to recognize the truth it holds.
Yet even with a simplified story like Animal farm, people are unable to recognize the truth it holds.
You uncritically believing propaganda by a rapist who enforced British colonial rule in India and snitched on communists and civil rights advocates doesn’t mean that it has any insight.
You miss the irony that in that piece of anti communist propaganda, it true warning is against the system that created it. Oligarchy.
the warning was that the “proletariat are stupid” and other dumb crap. Why do you think the CIA boosted his works?
Orwell was literally an enforcer of British colonial rule in India, and he was snitching to NATO’s spy agencies so that workers and non-white people wouldn’t have any rights.
The last thing he would be opposed to is oligarchy.
Removed by mod
Unexamined, gut-feeling anti-communism with no sources.
Removed by mod
a liberal classic: molotov-pact

But we’re not talking about the USA here
They also faced two massive external pressures that contributed to their failures:
- Western sanctions and trade restrictions limited access to markets, investment and technology.
- Foreign intelligence operations and Cold War hostility reinforced political paranoia at all levels and encouraged enormous spending on defence and internal security, along with weakened communication, trust and therefore internal co-operation.
These pressures didn’t just create additional problems, they made it far harder to address existing structural weaknesses inherent to their system.
Without those pressures, communist states would have had more resources, greater access to technology and a more stable political environment in which to pursue economic reform.
That doesn’t mean they would definitely have succeeded, but it does make it difficult to separate the inherent weaknesses of their economic systems from the hostile geopolitical conditions they operated within.
Exactly, and without living under the gun from the west would’ve removed the need for the society to be so regimented and militarized as well.
Singlehandedly in a very very narrow definition of singlehandedly.
They had heavy logistical and material supply from the USA.
I don’t think people understand the incredible amount of wealth the USA handed out to it’s allies through the lend lease program.
Oh that’s very interesting, let’s just see what the US Army literature has to say on the subject. https://lemmy.ml/post/55516121/29171523
Removed by mod
“…almost single-handedly…”
Hmm.
Yeah it’s true. While the rest of Europe kept making deals with Nazi Germany and then losing. It was the Soviets who defeated the Nazis.
Amerika came late to the party and took credit. And people genuinely think that it was Amerika that saved Europe. That’s the education system failing you.
Americans aren’t allowed to educate themselves, this won’t land on listening ears.
It’s not we’re not allowed – it’s that they made it as big of a pain in the ass as possible to learn it because they’ve learned that minimizing it is more effective than outright banning it.
Removed by mod
a % graph without any numbers from wikipedia lol okay
the Nazis were co-belligerents with the Soviets in the Polish invasion
Hey what did Poland do before this “Soviet invasion”?
It was the Soviets that gave the Nazis the resources to invade Europe
Oh, hey, a graph that only considers the timeline well after France and Britain finally attacked Germany. How did that equipment time-travel to the point before the second half of 1939?
or the fact that the Nazis were co-belligerents with the Soviets in the Polish invasion
Except, no, they were not. You are welcome to bring up, say, at least 5 Polish cities that you think the USSR “invaded”.
Also, the USSR did not get involved until after the Polish government went into exile.Also, I bet you are fine with Poland invading Ukraine and Belarus.
Removed by mod
No one is denying the effort and sacrifice made by the USSR on the eastern front. But the Soviets kept pushing for a second front (Africa, Italy and France). Hitler had little or no interest in the Africa front but kept it up because of how popular it was in the German public. Just the Norway subterfuge kept 300k German soldiers away from other fronts.
Except that’s what you lot are in fact doing. Downplaying the sacrifices the Soviets made on crushing the Nazi machine. Which would have been crushed sooner had Europe not kept making deals with Nazi Germany, hoping they would crush the Soviets. They fucking threw Czechoslovakia to the wolves even ffs
The Ribbentrop-Molotov deal was very convenient for Stalin. The Germans used Soviet territory to test new tech and methods away from prying Versailles treaty eyes.
Fucking lol

The Soviets were NEVER allies. They made the pact as a last resort to build up their industries after all of Europe refused to ally with the Soviets.
How Churchill was viewed as a warmonger for not wanting to do any if the pre 39 deals.
??? You fucking imbecile will call Stalin a monster or a warmonger but completely ignore Churchill being a fucking racist Nazi sympathizer who loved Mein Kampf.
Churchill didn’t give a FUCK about the Bengali famine, because in his words “Indians breed like rabbits”.
Churchill didn’t give a FUCK about the Bengali famine, because in his words “Indians breed like rabbits”.
Don’t accuse Churchill of not wanting to kill Indians.
deleted by creator
No one is denying the effort and sacrifice made by the USSR on the eastern front. But the Soviets kept pushing for a second front (Africa, Italy and France). Hitler had little or no interest in the Africa front but kept it up because of how popular it was in the German public. Just the Norway subterfuge kept 300k German soldiers away from other fronts.
You mean the second front that the US and the British empire were not opening until late in the war? How does that contradict what @EmmiLime@lemmy.ml said?
The Ribbentrop-Molotov deal was very convenient for Stalin. The Germans used Soviet territory to test new tech and methods away from prying Versailles treaty eyes.
Rather silly of you to bring up the Molotov-Ribbentrop agreement, considering that the USSR was pushing for an anti-German coalition at least as early as 1934 and as late as first half of 1939, and only signing the agreement after repeated denial by various parts of your empire, after the partition of Czechoslovakia, during which Poland acted on the side of Germany, and after multiple agreements by Poland, the British empire, the French empire, and other western powers with nazi Germany.
And if you buy into the cool aid that is Surov Stalin was preparing for his own war anyway.
What else do you think the USSR was doing if not delaying the war after repeated attempts to start an anti-German coalition?
US lend lease kept the Soviets in the game long enough for them to rebuild industrial capacity east of the Urals…
How much lend-lease support was given to the USSR before 1944?
I’ll let my British and Indian friends know, and all the resistance fighters, Poles, Scandinavians, French, etc. know they had nothing to do with it.
The British who wouldn’t join an anti-nazi alliance, who didn’t fight for Poland and who have up the rest of Europe?
Are you going to tell it to the 3.000.000 bengals who were starved to death by the british, or what population of the Indian subcontinent were you thinking of?
What french are you telling this to? The collaborators or those that spent most of their resources maintaining their colonial empire, who gave the Japanese the continued control of Indochina after the war until it could be staffed by French imperialists again?
What Scandinavians are you thinking of? The Danes from the “cream puff front”, the neutral swedes or the finns who fought alongside the axis?Yeah tell the British especially. Who were very much happy with Nazi Germany until they dared bomb THEM and not the Soviets. Who let millions of Indians starve during the Bengali famine because Churchill considered them like “breeding rabbits”.
And resistance fighters are not the ones who collaborated with the Nazis like their failed governments were.
That’s a very … unique … take on the history of WWII.
That’s a very… sad attempt at a rebuttal
It really isn’t, you just fall back on “erhm wow how…interesting, sweaty” because you don’t read and have no rebuttal
Am I wrong? Explain if so!
HOLD UP
What did you mean with “Scandinavians”?
You should elaborate on that more.
I won’t waste my time with you.
lmao bro thought Finland was based
Why? Because you’ll accidentally reveal your pro-Nazi views?
The British were fine and cooperative with Germany until 1939, and did not contribute nearly as much as the USSR (rather, just doing a genocide in India).
India fought on both sides, with many taking up arms against the British rule.
The Poles were also fine and cooperative with Germany until 1939, and the Polish resistance was still very concerned with Jewish people for some reason, even while dealing with German occupation.
What Scandinavian contribution do you claim, other than Quisling, the nazi siege of Leningrad and starvation of its civilians, and the attempted genocide in Karelia?
France folded very quickly in the war, and proceeded to become a German puppet. All after aiding Germany before 1939, together with the British empire and Poland.

Wait a minute. Day 5 and day 6… Is this why people don’t consider eating fish and poultry eating meat?
And then China did the same… capitalism doesn’t work. Communism creates progress and wealth for all.
deleted by creator
I wrote that communist China developed remarkably quickly under communism as did the USSR. What exactly are you disagreeing with?
A lot of liberals fly in to drop sarcastic turds, so trigger fingers occasionally lead to friendly fire.
sorry, I completely misread you, my bad
People are misreading what you wrote.
You do realize that neither the Soviet Union nor China were or are communist societies.
Both the PRC and the USSR were(/are) headed by communist parties. Both managed to achieve massive improvements in living standards of their people.
EDIT:
It’s amusing how much liberals hate the people of the PRC and the USSR that they think that stuff like guaranteed housing, healthcare, education, massive increases in life expectancy, and criminalisation of marital SA that benefit them are somehow bad.but have you considered billionaires told me china bad? that means china bad, your whole argument is now in shambles
Yes, the democratic republic of china
Yes.
The name is “People’s Republic of China”, yes.
Removed by mod
You are politically and socially illiterate. You gleefully gobble up the absolute sludge the US intelligence community vomits up about socialist states while somehow condemning the US as really bad, but clearly not as bad as the ‘definitely’ blacker than black socialist regimes. You need to read wider and more in-depth before anyone will take you seriously. Maybe take this as your moment to realise how horribly out of your depth you are and go and do some self-reflection and some education.
Maybe take this as your moment to realise how horribly out of your depth you are and go and do some self-reflection and some education.
A Dutch anti-Communist. What do you think?
Yet the United States of America has the largest prison population in the world.
Yet the United States of America is in endless wars.
Yet the United States of American is the only nation to use nuclear weapons (needlessly) in a war.
Communism works for all.
Yet the United States of America is in endless wars.
247 years of 250.
Removed by mod
You give one example of the worst capitalist state ever to have existed, while ignoring other stable, better working capitalist states.
You mean the states that keep invading Africa and Asia, and are committing at least one high-profile genocide right now?
You give one example of the worst capitalist state ever to have existed, while ignoring other stable, better working capitalist states. You give that as an argument to someone who’s also against capitalism.
STABLE? Yea dude like the riots in Europe? All of them becoming more and more fascist? What the fuck are you talking about lmao
My example is about ALL communist states. Not a single communist state went well, or better than a capitalist state without a horrible cost of lives, pain, suffering and opression (like the USSR and China).
Amerikan education system be like:
Removed by mod
liberals when scratched: THEY ARE UNTERMENSCH
fucking can’t live without the ableism
Removed by mod
but I’d prefer to not endure what the citizens of the USSR and China endured in those 50 years

The horror.
but I’d prefer to not endure what the citizens of the USSR and China endured in those 50 years.
lmao yeah, if I hated improved standards of living, food security, free education and free housing I would just move to mainland Europe or Amerika!
Better be born in the very capitalist Belgian Congo and enjoy the standards of people the Congolese enjoyed. /s
Surely you are referring to the Lebensraum and multiple invasions by what now constitutes NATO?
Removed by mod
scratched
ooops there it is another “whoopsie I forgot this was .ml”! so fucking adorable
Seems like you don’t actually have an issue with your empire’s invasions and genocides.
Removed by mod
wow so profound, one of those I’m 13 and this is deep moments
Removed by mod
“Almost lost” weird way to say “won”, liberal.
Removed by mod
Sorry we had to carry you in 2 wars, tankie.
LOL but Amerikans have never won a war post WW2 lmao
And even then your fascist country never did much except arrive late to take the credit and nuke 2 towns full of civilians.
Removed by mod

How did your moon landing go btw?
bruh this guy is genuinely desperate for a W
oh look another victim of American ‘education’ system
Now you just have to explain what the success of an authoritarian country under state capitalism has to do with communism.
Now you just have to learn what words mean.
That’s 21 words. “I don’t read history or theory and have no curiosity” says exactly the same thing with only 10 words.
Please say less.

















